Approaching for years of posts here at
Under Much Grace, I thought that it was about time for an index of
particularly pertinent posts concerning Vision Forum (VF), my primary
reason for blogging. I very likely will not keep updating it, but
this will at least help people navigate through the number of posts
that already appear here. (I've also included a list of important offsite links with additional info at the end of the list of posts.)
If you're looking for up to date
information about Vision Forum and a more comprehensive critique of
their doctrines, please visit Rethinking
Vision Forum. The hosts of that site have collected all
sorts of input from a wide variety of sources and perspectives, and
all of the material deals specifically with the problems of Vision
Forum's ideology.
Though it has been nearly four years
since I made the presentation, I believe that the best overview of
the topic can be viewed by watching the Patriarchy
Workshop Video from 2008. Though VF cleaned up their “Tenets
of Biblical Patrairchy” since that presentation and no longer teach
that women cannot vote, the remaining material remains quite
relevant.
I recommend starting your review here
with the series of posts here at Under Much Grace concerning
Multigenerational
Faithfulness. Until I studied the material concerning this
neologism that they created, I don't think that I fully appreciated
the extent of their distortion of Christian doctrine. Until I delved
into this study, well after I understood Vision Forum's perspective,
I believed that VF just taught some misguided doctrine but that the
core of their teaching was within the pale of orthodoxy. After
reviewing the material on Multigenerational
Faithfulness, my heart changed entirely. I now believe that they
preach a different gospel. It is not the message of God's grace
which is freely offered to us through the shed Blood and Sacrifice of
Jesus because of His great love for mankind. Vision Forum doesn't
even preach “replacement theology.” It is another gospel and a
tradition of a works. In Vision Forum, man becomes a New Adam, not a
new creation in Christ. Women are saved through a male intercessor.
That's another gospel.
OVERVIEW
About Patriarchy
- Online Video 2008 (1 hr in length)
- The Hegemonic Patriarchy (article by Sandlin)
Is Vision Forum Cultic (Spiritually
Abusive/Using Thought Reform Techniques?)
- Defining Terms
- What Makes a Cult a Cult? (doctrine vs behavior)
- Criteria
- How Can I Tell If My Church is Abusive? (Lifton's criteria)
Patriarchy and Vision Forum as
Postmodern Traditions of Men
- The Problematic Patriarchal Paradigm for Women (article originally published in Fidelity)
- Theological Innovations of Cultic Christianity (written in response to the Tenets of Biblical Patriarchy 2003)
DOCTRINES / NOVEL
PRACTICES
Multigenerational Faithfulness
- Collection and summary of several posts on the Under More Grace archive.
- Calvinism Becomes Twisted Karma (Odd interpretation of Replacement Theology)
Family Integrated Church
- Collection and summary of several posts on the Under More Grace archive.
- More Recent Post: How to Prepare Your 2 Year Old For Marriage
- Southern Baptist (SBC) Criticism of the Family Integrated Church Model According to Vision Forum (though many of their assumptions are so similar)
- Randy Stinson on the FIC
- A separate index dedicated to more articles about the Family Integrated Church
Tenets of Biblical Patriarchy
-
- More about the Colorado Home Educators
- Please also see the Patriarchy Workshop Video
Patriarchy, Kinism and the Southern
Cause (The South Will Rise Again!)
- Series on Neoconfederate Influence in Patriarchy on the Under More Grace archive.
- Index of posts concerning Kinism (racialism – convenient excuse for hatred of minorities)
Dominionism
Miscellaneous
- Perception: A Major Problem for Patriarchy (A collection of extra-Biblical preferences to form a lifestyle that is marketed as expressly Biblical)
CONCERNING WOMEN
The Religion of Daughterhood (Return
of the Daughters and the Botkins)
- Overcoming Botkin Syndrome (blog dedicated to the family dysfunction taught by Vision Forum and their affiliates, the Botkin Family)
- Dysfunctional Gender Dynamics within VF
- Visionary Daughters
- Return of the Daughters, Multigenerational Faithfulness, and Uncle Ned (contains links to other reviews and responses online)
- Review: The Disturbing Return of the Daughters (the “Visionary Daughters” video)
- Discussion of Covert Incest in response to the review
- Controlling the Visionary Daughters (report from a Homeschooling Conference)
- Combating Botkin Syndrome (link list) and Journey Out of Shame (link list)
-
- Offsite Links
- No Longer Quivering's Response to Vision Forum's Damage Control
- See “Refuting Vision Forum's View of Women” list of posts below
- About Geoffrey Botkin (from the Great Commission Bible-based cult of Jim McCotter)
- Who is Geoffrey Botkin? (A VF Recruit from the Cult of the Great Commission)
- A Botkin Update (the New Zealand Exit Strategy)
- The Significance of McCotter’s Great Commission (More about Botkin's origins and the plans of an exodus to New Zealand)
Refuting Vision Forum's View of
Women
- Blog Series Constrasting Patriarchy And Orthodox Judaism: Looking at Rabbi Maurice Lamm's book
- Offsite Link: Zelophehad's Daughters article at Hillary McFarland's Quivering Daughters website
- See“The Religion of Daughterhood” list of posts
Women and Voting
Women and College
Vision Forum's Teaching that Surgery
for Ectopic Pregnancy is Always Abortion and Murder
- Index of posts challenging Vision Forum's stance on Ectopic Pregnancy (including how they distorted and misrepresented the statistics)
Miscellaneous
- One of VF's Authors: Nancy Campbell (Women cannot become a new creation?)
VF DAMAGE CONTROL
Aggression Against Critics
- One day, you'll have to google how often they call their critics or ideas they don't like “Marxist” The accusations by Vision Forum are too numerous to count.
All Criticism is Gossip
- Cat in the Hat (about anti-gossip gossip)
Joe Taylor and the Allosaur Farce
- Offsite Link: Raising the Truth (Documentation that Phillips took credit for Joe Taylor's work, made and sold a confabulated documentary video about it, and then crushed Joe in court.)
HUMOR
Concerning Vision Forum and
Patriarchy
- Revisionist Art History (altered Leighton painting for a VF book cover)
- Preparing a 2 Year Old For Marriage (an actual NCFIC conference session)
OTHER IMPORTANT
OFFSITE LINKS
Midwest Christian
Outreach
- Who Will Be First in the Kingdom? (pdf journal)
- The Crux (VF related blog entries)
Gothard and Michael Pearl
Collaborate to Disown Vision Forum
(You know your doctrine is
way off when these two join forces to disavow you!)
Other
Links and Resources
- Don't forget Rethinking Vision Forum!
- The UnderMuchGrace Index of Gothard Articles
- Recovering Grace (website for recovery from ATI/IBLP)
- The UnderMuchGrace Link List
Last but not Least!