Under Much Grace

Pages

  • Home
  • Mission Statement and Bio
  • Navigating Under Much Grace and the Archives
  • Defining Spiritual Abuse (Index)
  • Note to New or Disgruntled Readers
  • Essential Viewing/Listening
  • Recommended Reading
  • Link List
  • Email Cindy

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Watch the Wave

Posted by Cindy at 1:05 PM
Labels: conformity studies, Films to Help You Process Your Experience

Newer Post Older Post Home

Concerning Things Cultic within Biblical Christianity

Spiritual Abuse describes the process by which a religious authority misuses power and the trust of their flock in order to meet their own needs or the needs of the system.

Many evangelical churches with sound and solid Biblical doctrine can be considered aberrant or "cultic" when they practice techniques of manipulation and thought reform.

Please read here concerning the many different aspects of this type of manipulation and spiritual abuse including development, practice and recovery from the phenomenon.

The blog title emphasizes that Christians live under the unmerited favor of God (grace) as opposed to earning favor with God. The notable aberrant and cultic system established by Bill Gothard redefines grace as something merited through the good work of submission to authority. Grace cannot be earned through submission to any law and comes by unmerited favor through faith alone!

You are not under law,
but under
grace.
Romans 6:14



Watchman Fellowship's Spiritual Abuse Profile

Watchman Fellowship's Spiritual Abuse Profile
Click on the graphic for more info



More About Spiritual Abuse

Click on a button below











Link to Additional Essential Reading on Spiritual Abuse

Link to Additional Essential Reading on Spiritual Abuse


Lifton's Dynamics of Coercive Groups

Lifton's Dynamics of Coercive Groups
Click on the graphic for more info and visit "Lifton" in the tag list.

Persuasion Techniques: Learn them and learn how to disarm them

Persuasion Techniques:  Learn them and learn how to disarm them
Click on the graphic for more info

Propaganda Techniques

  • ** Frequently used propaganda techniques in Spiritually Abusive groups
  • Ad Hominem - Attack your opponent's person rather than the argument itself. Literally "against the man"
  • Ad Hominem Abusive (Sub category of Ad Hominem) - An attack on the character or other irrelevant personal qualities of the opposition—such as appearance—is offered as evidence against their position. Such attacks are often effective distractions ("red herrings"), because the opponent feels it necessary to defend the self, thus being distracted from the topic of the debate.
  • Ad Hominem Circumstantial (Subcategory of Ad Hominem) -A Circumstantial Ad Hominem is one in which some irrelevant personal circumstance surrounding the opponent is offered as evidence against the opponent's position. This fallacy is often introduced by phrases such as: "Of course, that's what you'd expect him to say." The fallacy claims that the only reason why he argues as he does is because of personal circumstances, such as standing to gain from the argument's acceptance.
  • Appeal to Authority - Citing authorities or respected figures to support an argument or to discredit or negate an argument made by an opponent. This effectively thwarts the debate and the argument.
  • Appeal to Fear** - Fear is used to destabilize people so that they will be more likely to do or believe something that they would not otherwise choose under normal circumstances
  • Appeal to Force** (Argumentum ad Baculum) - Use of force and threats of force to "win" a debate. (baculum is a walking stick)
  • Appeal to Ignorance (also Argument from Silence) -An appeal to ignorance is an argument for or against a proposition on the basis of a lack of evidence against or for it. If there is positive evidence for the conclusion, then of course we have other reasons for accepting it, but a lack of evidence by itself is no evidence.
  • Appeal to Prejudice** - Using emotive terms and connotation to attach moral benefit or goodness to the argument. Attach the modifier "Biblical" to that which should not be questioned. "Cleanliness is next to godliness." It can also be used negatively. "The opinions and unrelated beliefs of a non-Christian cannot really be trusted, even regarding matters that do not relate to morality or Scripture."
  • Argumentum Ad Nauseum - An idea is repeated relentlessly until it is accepted. Especially effective when there is a great deal of milieu control.
  • Argumentum Ad Populum - (also called the "bandwagon" and "inevitable victory") Persuasion based on social proof
  • Big Lie - Create a message that is so complex but contains enough truthful elements so that people will not identify all the fictitious and fallacious elements. By the time it is recognized, many of the ideas are a part of the fabric of the debate and widely accepted.
  • Black-and-White Fallacy** (also called the Either-Or Fallacy or False Dilemma) - Presents information so that there are only two possible choices, one of which is far more appealing than the other. Obsures the difference between that which is contrary vs contradictory.
  • Common Man - Taking on of the characteristics of the target audience to make the message more palatable
  • Demonizing the Enemy** - Dehumanize the enemy and remove elements of commonality so that the target is easily dismissed, worthless, and of "non-person" status
  • Direct Order - Simplification of the decision making process so that followers will respond to very simple commands without question or need for additional problem solving
  • Euphoria - Use of emotionally charged and euphoria producing events to perpetuate good feelings and utopian ideals
  • Flag-waving - Capitalizing on patriotic sentiments to further one's agenda.
  • Glittering Generality - The use of positive connotation and vague statements to present an argument as very desirable without evidence to support glittering claims
  • Intentional Vagueness** (also "Fuzzy Logic") - Conclusions are not directly stated and the message may be intentionally vague so that individuals may draw their own conclusions, and the speaker does not have to be held directly accountable for the ideas. This works well in concert with other propaganda techniques.
  • Oversimplification (also "Fallacy of the Simple Cause") - Very complex processes are described with trite explanations that do not provide a faithful perspective for the target audience. Trite explanations are used to reduce rationales into faulty causalities.
  • Quoting Out of Context (type of "Straw Man" argument) - Selected quotes are extracted from a passage so that without the full context of the passage, the meaning is greatly distorted.
  • Rationalization** - Positive and unrelated aspects of something are offered as evidence for an argument's validity. "But they can't teach wrong doctrine because they have a lovely family"
  • Red Herring - (large category of several fallacies) Irrelevant but compelling aspects of an argument are offered as a distraction from the core issues in order to derail the debate.
  • Redefinition** - Assigning new meaning to an old term, but this is a logical boobytrap because of the ease of equivocation and confusing meanings. "He who defines, wins."
  • Reductio ad Hitlerum (type of Red Herring - see also Transference) - Suggestion that a popular idea is associated with something deplorable, hateful and unthinkable so that people will react and reject the argument or source of information based on the association.
  • Repetition - A rhetorical or literary device that is lyrical and gets stuck in one's mind like an advertising jingle. It is akin to argumentum ad nauseum, but also has literary quality.
  • Scapegoating** - A single cause or element is identified and vilified as the source of all undesirable circumstances or outcomes. The scapegoat distracts the audience from other possible contributing factors.
  • Slogans - Short phrases or motto used to make emotional appeals and support ideas. Slogans become "thought stopping" techniques quickly and become communication shortcuts that suspend critical thought.
  • Steriotyping (also "Name Calling" or "Labeling") - Reduces people, events, practices or ideas to capitalize on prejudice to evoke fear or distain.
  • Straw Man** - The Prince of All Fallacies (Subtype of "Red Herring") - Attempt to refute an opponent's position, and in the context is required to do so, but instead attacks a position—the "straw man"—not held by the opponent. Argues to a conclusion that denies the "straw man" the arguer has set up, but misses the target. A common straw man is an extreme man. Extreme positions are more difficult to defend because they make fewer allowances for exceptions, or counter-examples.
  • Testimonial - Reports or testimony from trusted sources are offered, out of context, in support of or for vilification of an idea, person, etc.
  • Transference** - Projection of either positive or negative qualities to something or someone in order to connote qualities that may or may not be related. It capitalizes on emotional response and is related to "Guilt by Association" and "Reductio ad Hitlerum"
  • Unstated Assumption** - Beliefs are implied or stated indirectly because a direct statement would seem less credible. "Women's suffrage is outside the prescriptive will of God and Kingdom Architecture." As a woman and a voter, you now have been told that you are acting outside the will of God and willingly disobedient. Any Christian understands that willful disobedience of God and the Scriptures is sin. The speaker can imply that they have not accused anyone of sinning, skirting accountability; however their inference that voting for women is a sin is understood.

More About Aberrant Christianity

~ Click a button below to link to more information about specific ABERRANT groups, individuals and topics within Evangelical Christianity ~











About Brainwashing

About Brainwashing
Click on image for more information

Blog Archive

My Favorite Titles on Spiritual Abuse

Also, see other book and film lists on this sidebar that aid and support one's recovery from the far reaching effects of spiritual abuse. For suggestions about how to prioritize, refer to this suggested list.

Healing the Mind After Disappointment and Trauma

Thurman and Amen, both Christians, present helps to right thinking, what the psychologist calls "cognitive behavioral therapy" and what the Christian calls "spiritual warfare" and "bringing every thought captive."

Dealing with Forgiveness and Disappointment ~~ Healing Our Relationships

Fundamental Baptist Fellowship International's 2006 Resolution Against the Family Integrated Church

  • The Family Integrated Church Movement was deemed "errant and schismatic" because....
  • * It encourages schism in the local church bodies by encouraging its adherents to change the theology and philosophy of the churches of which they are members.
  • * It does violence to local church authority, calling on local church members to leave their churches when the church does not bow to the philosophical demands of the movement.
  • * It espouses an ecclesiology based upon the family that is not based upon the New Testament but rather is an adaptation of Old Testament (Blog host note: ? or pagan Roman ?!) patriarchy.
  • * It falsely lays the claim that the destruction of the family in the U.S. is solely the fault of age-graded ministries in local churches. We contend that this is a simplistic and therefore false accusation.
  • * It espouses a postmillennial theology that is contradictory to a dispensational understanding of Scripture.
  • * It is oddly inclusive, basing fellowship on a particular philosophy of ministry rather than on the great fundamentals of the faith.

Listen to the BTR Archives

Listen to internet radio with jocelyn andersen on Blog Talk Radio

Labels

  • abuse (domestic) (21)
  • apologetics (12)
  • behavior (control via incremental changes) (6)
  • Bible study difficulties (7)
  • black and white thought (6)
  • Book Recommendations (14)
  • bounded choice (4)
  • brain and mind (10)
  • Calvinism Fringe becomes karma (8)
  • Childhood Roots of Victimization (Complex PTSD) (17)
  • Christian Existentialism (11)
  • Christian Reconstructionism (23)
  • Church attendance decline (11)
  • Cialdini (16)
  • CNN/Cooper Ungodly Discipline (9)
  • Codependency and spiritual abuse (20)
  • cognitive dissonance (45)
  • College for Girls (5)
  • con artists/cult leaders (33)
  • Conference Survival Skills (9)
  • conformity studies (9)
  • confrontation/discipline/Matt 18 (27)
  • courtship (7)
  • Covert (non-sexual) Incest (56)
  • cult definition (7)
  • cults (36)
  • cycle of abuse (2)
  • damage control (7)
  • Danvers Statement (22)
  • Defining Spiritual Abuse (2)
  • discernment (17)
  • discipline (child) (55)
  • discipline (church) (24)
  • discipline (domestic) (6)
  • Dominionism (17)
  • Doubling of personality in abusers (5)
  • ectopic pregnancy (13)
  • effects of spiritual abuse (3)
  • Elements of Spiritual Abuse (13)
  • emergent church (16)
  • Enlightenment (9)
  • exit counseling (17)
  • experience of realizing spiritual abuse (6)
  • Family Integrated Church History (24)
  • fascism (7)
  • FIC (58)
  • FIC Rejected by Baptists (5)
  • Films to Help You Process Your Experience (3)
  • First Time Obedience (8)
  • forgiveness v. reconciliation (2)
  • gender (60)
  • generation gap (10)
  • gossip (7)
  • Gothard (35)
  • Great Commission Cult (4)
  • Hephzibah House (44)
  • hermeneutics (10)
  • Holidays (14)
  • homeschooling (34)
  • hypnosis (6)
  • IFB (42)
  • Index of Blog Posts and Links (9)
  • inspirational (18)
  • Judaism Contrasted Against Patriarchy (19)
  • Kidney Disease related to Pearl (4)
  • kinism (21)
  • leaving a manipulative group (4)
  • Lifton (20)
  • Lifton 101 (11)
  • Lifton: Cult of Confession (1)
  • Lifton: Demand for Purity (1)
  • Lifton: Dispensing of Existence (1)
  • Lifton: Doctrine Over Person (14)
  • Lifton: Loaded Language (10)
  • LIfton: Milieu Control (7)
  • Lifton: Mystical Manipulation (3)
  • Lifton: Sacred Science (2)
  • Love Addiction/Love Avoidance (9)
  • Machiavellianism (10)
  • marital issues (42)
  • marriage (from The Jewish Way in Love and Marriage) (19)
  • militant fecundity (6)
  • misreading the Bible (7)
  • multigenerational faithfulness (18)
  • neologism/language (21)
  • Patriarchy Video (10)
  • Patriarchy Video Commentary (14)
  • Pearl (1)
  • Pearl (Michael) (18)
  • perspective (10)
  • PODCASTS on PATRIOCENTRISM (2)
  • politics (9)
  • postmodern (19)
  • product/book review (19)
  • Prophet Priest King of the Home (2)
  • psychopathy/socipathy (8)
  • PTSD (27)
  • Quivering Daughters (3)
  • racism (19)
  • Random BLoggers and VLoggers (11)
  • resisting influence (27)
  • Resources (23)
  • Return of the Daughters (9)
  • Right Wing Populism (2)
  • sanctification (7)
  • Scripture concerning false prophets (3)
  • self-blame in abuse (5)
  • sexual abuse (26)
  • Shame Resources (6)
  • shepherding/discipleship (3)
  • Southern Cause (9)
  • spiritual abuse (39)
  • Spiritual Abuse (Experience of Realizing You Have Been Abused) (4)
  • Spiritual Covering (1)
  • SPIRTUAL ABUSE PODCAST Companion Posts (15)
  • statistics and manipulation (7)
  • submission doctrine (2)
  • techniques (47)
  • Teen Mania (5)
  • thought reform (23)
  • tolerance (10)
  • totalitarian niceness (10)
  • Trinity (ESS) (18)
  • unChristian (9)
  • unwritten rules in churches (4)
  • Vision Forum (80)
  • Why Good People Make Dangerous Choices (13)
  • witnessing (3)
  • woman's rights in marriage (7)
  • Zimbardo (7)

View and Download Powerpoint Slides

Get your own Widget
Copyright by
CM Kunsman of and Under Much Grace
2007 - 2012 All rights reserved.


Copyrighted works are made available here under the 'fair use' exception of U.S. copyright law, for research and educational purposes only.



Quivering Daughters Blog

Quivering Daughters Blog

Visit...

Visit...

Watch Freedom for Christian Women Coalition Videos!

SEO - search engine submission and optimisation

Visit the Take Heart Project

Visit the Take Heart Project

Visit....

Visit....


Picture Window template. Template images by Storman. Powered by Blogger.